Guitar101
Moderator   Posts: 447 Registered: 12/22/2003 Status: Offline
|
 posted on 8/1/2004 at 23:40 |
So how does Jimmy Page stand on your list. Do you like his playing? Sound?
Songwriting?
____________________
|
| |
chrisC
Captain   Posts: 150 Registered: 7/29/2004 Status: Offline |
 posted on 8/1/2004 at 23:56, Reply 1 |
YES I LOVE JIMMY PAGE GREATEST EVER!!!!!!!!!!!!! but umm thanks for giving
me credit for coming up with the idea for this post!  nah i dont care.
JIMMY PAGE IS THE GREATEST!!!!!!!!!
|
| |
Spidercents
Moderator  Posts: 998 Registered: 7/29/2004 Status: Offline |
posted on 8/2/2004 at 00:20, Reply 2 |
| I like jimmy in led zeppelin.However after zep I havent liked anything hes
has done.I loved zep at one time however have worn out on it.I listend to
it way to much.Jimmy is not that great of a player live.On the song remains
the same everyone played well except for jimmy who I thought struggled
thruogh the whole concert.John bonams drums were to loud,however john
played well.John was the band.Without his drum riffs and timings 75% of
Zeps songs would never of been wrote.He brought the best out of jimmy which
nobody else has done to this day.Jimmy is a studio genious and can capture
moments on tape most of us forget to do.So hes a great player in the studio
sense.I think of him as more of a producer than a great guitar player.I
think he recorded everthing he played and had great moments that were
captured that might never come again.So for that hes great. ____________________
Treat people the way you would want to be treated.
|
| |
chrisC
Captain Posts: 150 Registered: 7/29/2004 Status: Offline |
posted on 8/2/2004 at 01:02, Reply 3 |
you must be a drummer! thats ok tho.
page and bonam were a great pair. which probably explains why you didnt
like jimmy after zeppelin. bonam (which i think is actually spelled bonham,
but ill continue to spell it this way) worked off of page as well. a great
example of this is"the ocean". the drums (snare especially) song fit
perfect in that song. and if im correst page came up with the opening riff
before bonam wrote the drum part. (which is usually how most songs are made
guitar part then drums)
theres a chance that when you saw zep page was drunk. they were a haevy
drinking band .bonham drank himself to death. and it sounds to me that you
are judging jimmy on his performance after zeppelin. just because you dont
liek his music doesnt mean he wasnt a great player. but this topic is
different from the one i had previopusly posted which simply asked does he
make your top 10 list. but thats ok. i love zep which is probably why im
defending page so much. that and this one dvd i saw page playing his
fingers where flying all over the palce amazing speed, and he didnt miss a
note.
o yeah i forgot stairway to heaven. dont try to tell me that the every
drummer takes time to learn the amazing drum part in that song. every
single person on the face of the earth could hum you that song. the truth
is theres no zeppelin song where the drum parts made the song or were just
real memorable, maybe rock n roll, but if you ask me that drum solo just
annoys me.
jimmy page drove zeppelin!
|
| |
Spidercents
Moderator Posts: 998 Registered: 7/29/2004 Status: Offline |
posted on 8/2/2004 at 03:27, Reply 4 |
He dosent play well live drunk or not.Drummers do learn stairway.
I like Jimmy in zep.Anything else like outrider(I think thats the name) or
whatever is not that good to me.Bohnams playing was the key to the
band.Robert Plant will tell you that.I'm not discrediting jimmy on any
riffs or licks.Like I said he probably recorded everything he did.I thought
jimmy was the greatest at one time too.However I now realize the impact
john bohnams drumming was.He was the backbone of zep.I'm not discrediting
anything jimmy wrote.I didnt say anything to make you think that.I'm not a
drummer.Guitar is my thing.Hopfully youll see the impact his drumming had
on jimmys playing and vice versa of course.John fed off of jimmy to however
the timings that john had took it to a place that no one else could.The
bass player was very good too.He dosent get enough credit. ____________________
Treat people the way you would want to be treated.
|
| |
Guitar101
Moderator Posts: 447 Registered: 12/22/2003 Status: Offline |
posted on 8/2/2004 at 08:57, Reply 5 |
Jimmy was very inventive and has left his mark on the guitar world. It's
all 4 that made the band not just one guy. Team work!
____________________
|
| |
Spidercents
Moderator Posts: 998 Registered: 7/29/2004 Status: Offline |
posted on 8/2/2004 at 13:34, Reply 6 |
Guitar 101 has said it best.All 4.
Out of ten I rate Jimmy like this
His Album play-# 8 to # 10 out of ten
His live playing-#bad #really bad
I cant listen to the song remains the same because his playing is so bad.I
believe I read A quote from Eddie van Halen that said Jimmy played like a
five year old when playing live.I agree. ____________________
Treat people the way you would want to be treated.
|
| |
chrisC
Captain Posts: 150 Registered: 7/29/2004 Status: Offline |
 posted on 8/2/2004 at 15:02, Reply 7 |
i listened to botth the live and studio versions of the song remains the
same, and with an exception to some fans screaming and some extra feedback
(nothing to serious) it was the same.
jimmy page is a great guitar player 10 out of 10. anyways i think your
jealous of his performance in the song remains the same. i bet you cant
even play it. ____________________
|
| |
Telefreak
Moderator  Posts: 440 Registered: 1/12/2004 Status: Offline |
posted on 8/2/2004 at 20:38, Reply 8 |
I don't mean to be rude Spidercents, but you're talking poop.
I have the most recent Led Zep DVD that covers footage from the entire span
of thier career and there's sweet FA wrong with his live performances.
I live Jimmy Page becase the best Led Zep stuff was recorded on a
Telecaster.
1.Stairway to heaven
2.Communication brakdown
3.Dazed and confused
and so on. :giggly: ____________________
Technology, not technique
|
| |
brian
Moderator  Posts: 1038 Registered: 12/22/2003 Status: Offline |
 posted on 8/3/2004 at 01:08, Reply 9 |
Jimmy Page was great just sloppy. 4 out of 5 in my book
|
| |
